Why Destructive Entrepreneurs Earn the Most, or How to Find Out Your Income Ceiling

What Is the Point of Business?

Why do some entrepreneurs create innovations and become millionaires, while others become billionaires by creating almost nothing or even destroying? The answer has nothing to do with greed, corruption, or competition. It has to do with the fact that most entrepreneurs do not understand at all what value is.

Doing business without understanding the nature of value is like doing theology without mentioning God. It is impossible to build a sustainable enterprise—an actual enterprise, not just individual deals—that does not create value for its customers. Or is it? It turns out there are entrepreneurs who destroy value but still earn excellently. Let us figure out how this is possible, whether it can be learned, and what your personal income ceiling is.

First, let us determine what value is. Any answer that refers to costs, labor, raw materials, or capital is fundamentally wrong—the customer does not care how or with what effort the product was produced; what matters is what this product will give them. That is, value for the customer lies in the future, and since the future is always undetermined, that future will happen with some probability. To be formal, value (V) has a probabilistic-temporal character and equals the time (T) that a product or service can give to (or save for) the consumer, multiplied by the probability (P) that this will happen:

V = T × P — this is the formula of value. (For the foundations of the theory of value, see here.)

(For the very curious: strictly speaking, the value of a resource equals the total lost time of the consumer if they do not use this resource, multiplied by the probability that this loss will actually occur without this resource—that is why a glass of water in the desert costs so much: the whole of life is at stake.)

This is why protein food is generally more expensive than plant food: it provides more calories, and therefore more time. This is why people prefer fast transport to slow transport when the task is to reach the destination rather than enjoy the journey itself. And this is why an experienced doctor is more expensive than a novice: the probability that he will cure you, i.e., preserve your lifetime, is noticeably higher.

The Pyramid of Value Creation

What do entrepreneurs have to do with this, you ask. The fact is that entrepreneurs earn noticeably more than their employees not because of greed or exploitation, but because they create the main value. But they do this in different ways, including through the destruction of value, paradoxical as it may sound. To understand how they do it, let us go through the pyramid of value creation.

If we look at the pyramid of value creation, at the very bottom are linear employees—the first level. They work with an environment of varying degrees of predictability. The more predictable the environment, the lower the value created, because less uncertainty is removed—on an assembly line, in harvesting, or as a street cleaner, they are paid the least. The environment can be more complex and less predictable—disease, program code, piloting an aircraft. The reward of such workers is noticeably higher. Overall, the contribution of linear employees is local and very limited in its influence on both T and P. They reduce local risk, but not systemic risk. But there are exceptions at this level too, if it is possible to scale the results of local labor to a huge number of consumers almost for free, i.e., sharply increase the T created. For example, the ability to copy the result of a musician’s labor almost for free and without limit turned many musicians from vagabonds into millionaires; something similar happened to many app creators. Hairdressers, for example, are not destined for such a fate.

The second level of the value creation pyramid is management. Management works with a substantially more unpredictable environment—people. They get sick, make mistakes, quarrel, compete, strive for something, burn out, invent. If a linear worker is more like a blacksmith working with predictable metal, then a manager is like a juggler, with no time at all for a breather and an environment changing too quickly. Managing people, i.e., the ability to overcome uncertainty in a human collective, removes more uncertainty than working with a material environment. Therefore, the reward of managers is generally higher than that of linear workers. They influence T more because they aggregate the labor of many linear workers and influence P more strongly through optimizing local business processes.

The third level is entrepreneurs. They work with the most complex and unpredictable environment—the market. In the market, uncertainty is created by all its participants—customers, linear employees and management of other companies, weather, politicians, scientists, criminals, i.e., the whole society. They create new products that significantly increase T (save or add lifetime) and are able to remove the highest uncertainty, i.e., that related to the market (increase P in the value formula). It is for this that the entrepreneur receives the greatest reward.
Did you find yourself in this pyramid of value creation? Do you see where you are moving?

Who Are Destructive Entrepreneurs

But not all entrepreneurs are the same, because they work with the market differently. Entrepreneurs can be divided into two groups—constructive and destructive.

A constructive entrepreneur is a type of entrepreneur who works by the rules of the market. That is, by the rules established by the state and existing institutions, which include laws, taxes, tariffs, subsidies, benefits, i.e., the whole set of mechanisms by which the state tries to direct market forces to its advantage. This is the environment of the “red ocean,” as it was eloquently called in the book Blue Ocean Strategy by professors Kim and Mauborgne; in other words, an environment of maximum, literally bloody, competition. Business mortality in such an environment is extremely high. But it is precisely in it that innovators mature who change the market from within—they create new products with incredible value, i.e., in which T or P sharply increase. And the greater these indicators, the greater the reward: it could be a weight-loss product, a new type of battery, or a smartphone.

A destructive entrepreneur is a type of entrepreneur who does not work by the rules of the market. I am not talking about lawbreakers, who cannot be considered entrepreneurs at all; I am talking about those who change the rules to suit themselves through interaction with the state and institutions. When legislation, rules of bidding and tenders, tariffs, benefits, rules of listing on an exchange are changed—the set of mechanisms here is very broad and does not necessarily require corruption. Such entrepreneurs, using their influence, create for themselves a local artificial monopoly, in which risk for them becomes minimal and for the consumer maximal. This can be, for example, as primitive a thing as a direct requirement that only suppliers with revenue of at least X participate in a municipal tender, while the market has only one such supplier, belonging to a particular respected person; or it may be a subtler situation, when some stock exchanges in principle change listing conditions for a particular large issuer so that another respected person can become a trillionaire.

Monopoly creates a situation in which the risk of not using a good or service rises sharply, because there is no competition. The consumer is put in the position of a traveler in the desert—if you don’t want to buy at a high price, go walk the dunes, bargain. That is, (T)—the lifetime that the consumer may lose—is enormous, and the chance that he will lose it (P) tends to 100%, i.e., in the consumer’s eyes the value of the resource V = T × P rises sharply.

It is precisely this asymmetric risk profile that makes destructive entrepreneurs the richest—they receive a reward as if they were reducing enormous risk, while themselves bearing minimal risk. That is, a huge reward at minimal cost.

Such an approach is destructive because, instead of creating new value, such entrepreneurs—who are rightly called destructive—create conditions in which already existing solutions begin to be artificially filled with inflated value. That is, destructive entrepreneurs do not create something new; they imitate innovations and force people to pay more for what already exists.

Economic Progress Is Not GDP Growth

Different skills in overcoming uncertainty, that is, in creating value, lead to the fact that in society the top is inevitably occupied mainly by people with an entrepreneurial type of thinking and abilities. They may be cautious reformers or radical revolutionaries, but in any case they must be people capable of managing precisely the type of uncertainty that entrepreneurs face—a huge external unpredictable environment and people managing other people.

Such a fundamental nature of value makes societies fully governed by hired workers—for example, workers and peasants—fundamentally impossible. A governing class is inevitably required, i.e., a stratum of people with an entrepreneurial (not necessarily in the commercial sense) type of thinking. For example, in a planned economy, this function was performed by the party apparatus.

Overall, within the Probabilistic-Temporal Theory of Value (PTTV), entrepreneurship is not a profession but a special type of cognitive work with uncertainty, aimed at reducing systemic risk in a complex environment. It does not depend on the type of society or the type of commodity-money relations, i.e., it is universal.

Unfortunately, the transition from constructive to destructive entrepreneurship is equally universal, because it banaly gives more income for substantially less risk, and at the level of an individual transaction the formula V = T × P confirms this without any stretching: the client really does pay for the P that has actually increased for him. Here lies the trap. If you look at each transaction separately, the constructive and destructive entrepreneur are indistinguishable—both honestly, according to the formula, earn on increased V.

The difference is visible only at the level of society as a whole. A constructive entrepreneur increases society’s aggregate T × P—a new resource appears, and the sum of value available to all grows. A destructive entrepreneur adds nothing to this sum—he takes the already existing T × P from a cornered consumer and transfers it to himself. One plants a tree. The other simply fences off an already growing forest and sells the right of entry. At the same time, with the flourishing of destructive entrepreneurship, noticeable GDP growth may well be observed, since the number of economic transactions and their value can grow. That is why economic progress is not GDP growth, but, according to the probabilistic-temporal understanding of value, the growth of society’s ability to manage future time and future risks, i.e., the ability to create genuine rather than illusory value.

“The Paradox of the High Value of Hunger” — A Section for Those Who Noticed the Catch
Imagine a situation: a certain super-influential destructive entrepreneur has bought up or destroyed 99% of the food on the planet, leaving people on the brink of starvation.

According to the value formula: V = T × P:

  • T (time) — for a hungry person, their entire remaining life is at stake
  • P (probability) — even without a small portion of food, the person will die, P → 100%
  • V (value) — for a person, each portion of food is enormous

It would seem a paradox: the monopolist has created colossal value, because people are ready to give all their property for a ration, work in slavery, sacrifice everything. Does this not prove that destructive entrepreneurship can create enormous value?

No. And here is why.

The Difference Between a Local Desert and a Global Desert

In the classic example of a glass of water in the desert, value tends toward the price of a whole life, because the macro-future is preserved. A person understands: after drinking this glass, he can reach an oasis or encounter another water source and live another 40 years.

  • P → 100% (without the glass I will die now)
  • T — very large (all possible remaining life)
  • V — very large, literally decades

But when a destructive entrepreneur creates an artificial total scarcity (destroys all food/economy), he turns the whole world into a desert, where there is no oasis or other alternatives on the horizon.

And here the key logic comes into play:

  • Yes, without food/water a person will die today (P → 100%).
  • But even if he consumes this food/water, he has nowhere to go. Tomorrow there will still be no food/water. The ecosystem is killed.
  • Consequently, the maximum future (T) that can be saved by this transaction is limited to hours or days.
  • V in that case is very small!

Value is not infinite! It is rigidly limited by the dying horizon of the system. The value of any resource is bounded above by the maximum future that this resource is capable of preserving.

Original version of the article is here.