In early August, SpaceX shares fell noticeably; investors were frightened by the growth of AI expenses. It would seem an ordinary market event. But behind it stands a question that most market participants prefer not to ask out loud: what exactly are they buying when they take securities of a company without a long history of financial results? I am a hands-on financier with almost thirty years of experience, and this question has occupied me for a long time — not in an academic, but in the most applied sense.Two Games with Different DiceImagine: you are playing dice. In the first variant — an ordinary die, six faces, the probability of each is precisely known. In the second — you do not know either the number of faces, or their ratios, or what numbers are even written on them. In the first case you are dealing with risk, in the second — with uncertainty. The difference is fundamental: risk can be calculated and the probability of an outcome assessed, while where this cannot be done, convincing anyone that, for example, a thousand will come up is no harder than any other number.
In the world of investments, this difference determines a great deal. In the value of any company there are always two components:
- The first relies on measurable data: statistics, cash flows, real results. This is the domain of risk and knowledge.
- The second relies on expectations — hopes, scenarios, stories about the future. This is the domain of uncertainty and faith.
Why Traditional Methods StallClassical valuation tools — DCF, comparative analysis, the cost approach — are created to work with the first component. They assume that you know future cash flows fairly precisely, can correctly discount them, and can find sufficiently similar companies for comparison.
With young technology companies without a long history of profits and a time-tested business model, the situation is even more acute. There are almost no measurable data, but there are a great many expectations. And the more grandiose the story about the future, the higher the valuation.
That is precisely why SpaceX is worth hundreds of billions of dollars not because current financial indicators explain such a figure. But because the expectations around it are more grandiose than any current indicators. AI companies trade at prices that in no way follow from their current revenues; their valuation rests on expectations, not on numbers.
SpaceX and Bitcoin: An Unobvious SimilarityBitcoin is the limiting case. It cannot generate cash flow in principle, so almost one hundred percent of its price is formed by expectations and speculation. Does it have real value? Yes, it provides the ability to transfer money bypassing currency controls, sanctions, and banking restrictions. A concrete benefit that is definitely not equal to zero. But it explains none of the peaks of the fall or rise in its value — it simply gets lost in speculative noise.
SpaceX is not Bitcoin. The company has real revenue, technological achievements, a real business. But the share of measurable, fundamental value in the current valuation is relatively small; the main part of the price is a bet on a future scenario that so far exists only as a possibility. And here begins the zone of pure uncertainty: no one knows how many faces this die has. In essence, in both cases the market largely sells expectations regarding the future, and not already proven value.
What Exactly Does the Investor BuyWhen current financial indicators do not explain the price, the investor buys one of two things, or both at once.
The first — the probability of the future scenario being realized. That SpaceX will indeed make the technological breakthrough its founders talk about. That a specific AI company will indeed change the economy as it promises. That Bitcoin will become established as a key way to transfer money bypassing banks and state control and because of this will only rise in price.
The second — the hope for the next buyer, that is, a bet not on the company creating such-and-such value, but on the fact that in a year someone else will want to pay more for it. Classical speculative logic, which in itself is not bad, but requires honest awareness. A productive asset creates value by itself; a speculative one is worth exactly as much as the next buyer is ready to pay for it.
One of the popular arguments in favor of high valuations of technology companies is the analogy with those high-tech companies that achieved success in previous periods of technological change. The argument is attractive, but creates false precision: finding a truly similar asset is extremely difficult, and for a young technology company — practically impossible. When you compare an organization that bets on a technological breakthrough in a fundamentally new area with any known successful example — this is no longer a comparison of similar assets, but a comparison of the measurable with the immeasurable. Not to mention survivorship bias: we remember the winners and forget about the many losers.
How to Think About These AssetsAny asset should be evaluated primarily by its fundamental value, and not by its current price. Price can change greatly under the influence of rumors, fears, hopes, and other market factors. Fundamental value is far more stable. At least theoretically, it can be calculated independently of market sentiment and the investor's personal expectations. According to the Probability-Time Theory of Value (PTTV), the fundamental value of any asset is determined by two parameters: the time it is capable of creating or saving, and the probability that this will actually happen:
V = T × P.Here it is fundamentally important that it is time, not money. Money constantly changes its ability to be converted into goods, services, and other values, whereas time has unchanging value: an hour today is equal to an hour in a hundred years and to an hour a thousand years ago.
At the same time, price is connected with fundamental value and on the whole serves as its indicator, although it can both approach it and deviate significantly from it. The more valuable an asset, the higher the potential demand for it and, as a consequence, its price. And vice versa.
In simplified form, value can be represented as expected discounted future income multiplied by the probability of its realization:
V ≈ C = M × P, where
M is expected discounted income, and
P is the probability of its realization.
Applied to SpaceX, AI companies, and crypto assets, this means two honest questions — not optimistic, but realistic:
- When and under what circumstances is the asset capable of justifying its value with a high degree of reliability (what is the realistically achievable T, or, expressed in monetary units — what is the realistically achievable level of income M)?
- What is the probability of such a scenario being realized (what is the real P)?
SpaceX at a valuation of hundreds of billions presupposes the realization of a scenario whose probability is so far not high. For AI companies the question is even more acute: the promises are enormous, but when and how they will turn into real results is so far unknown. At the same time, for many companies the question of how to scale their monetization remains open.
Main PointA high market price is not equal to high fundamental value — these are different things, and confusing them is a sure path to losing investments. Bitcoin, AI startups, SpaceX can bring enormous profit, but will it turn out to be sufficient to justify current prices, and how likely is it that this scenario will be realized? But there is another important question. There is hardly any doubt that new technologies will remain and will bring benefit. But this does not mean that precisely today's market leaders will benefit most from their spread. As a wise investor once said: in an era when many new automobile companies were displacing horses from the roads, the best investment was not a bet on new companies, since guessing the winner was very difficult, but a bet against horse-drawn companies, which would certainly lose.
Choose between valuation and expectations. The higher the expectations — the higher the price; the higher the price — the more exuberant the fantasy, and so on in a circle, right up to the moment when expectations meet reality. Bitcoin has already gone through this cycle several times, and each time the market managed to be surprised.
The world of investments today is a market where measurable risk and immeasurable uncertainty are mixed so densely that they are difficult to distinguish by eye. That is precisely why working with assets of the "new economy" requires not new valuation models first of all, but an honest answer to a simple question: what exactly am I buying?
If you understand that you are taking not a calculable business, but a beautiful story — act consciously, since the risk of being mistaken is extremely high. If you are sure that you know the future that no one else knows — you are not an investor, you are a gambler. That is your legal right, but confusing one with the other is not a good idea.
The original article is
here.