How Much Is a Company Worth: Why the Price of a Business May Not Reflect Its Real Value

“There is no single objective price; there is a price for a specific buyer here and now, in specific circumstances.”

Two entrepreneurs are discussing the sale of a business. One is the founder, who has been building the company for ten years, knows every process, assembled the team from scratch, and personally knows all the key clients. The other is a strategic investor: he already has a similar business in another region, and he is buying not so much the company as access to the market and a ready-made team. The appraiser names a figure: 100 million rubles. The founder is sure the business is worth twice that. The investor thinks it is worth half. Evgeny Sedinkin, an economist and financier, told the Biz360.ru portal why comparable transactions and financial forecasts are not important when calculating price.

Value Is Not the Same as Price

We are used to thinking of value as a property of the object itself. A house is worth such and such, a business is worth such and such—as if it were a physical characteristic like mass. But that is not so, and value always has three components: the object itself, the circumstances, and the subject.

A bottle of water in the city costs 50 rubles, but the same bottle in the desert becomes priceless. Yet the water itself has not changed at all: only the circumstances have changed.

According to the Probability-Time Theory of Value that I have developed, the value of any good lies in the future, not in costs or someone’s opinion. That future consists of saved time, adjusted for the probability that this will happen:

V = T × P, where T is saved time, and P is the probability that it will actually be preserved.

Simply put: the value of an asset is its ability to preserve the future, measured in time. And it is always tied to a person and circumstances—there is no single “value in general” for a specific asset.

For the owner, a business is not just an asset but part of his life, reputation, and identity. Parting with it means losing access to a future that was built over years. For the investor, it is just one asset in a portfolio: losing it will adjust the trajectory of the investor’s life but will not change it fundamentally. Therefore, for him the objective value of this business is indeed noticeably lower.

The formula V = T × P also works in reverse. Even a modest-profit business can be significantly more valuable if the probability that it will continue to exist and earn is very high—thanks to stable processes, a diversified client base, and independence from any one single person. Conversely, possible future large profits with a low probability of a sustainable future create less real value than it seems from the financial statements and models.

The same logic works even with ordinary money, although it seems that, for example, 1,000 rubles is worth the same to everyone. But that is not so. To a millionaire, 1,000 rubles means almost nothing—they cannot change his future. For a person who is starving, the same amount can be salvation and prolong life until better times. Judging value by a single number is the same as judging an entire curve by a single point.

Why Price Is Not Value

Price is merely the point at which the demand curve intersects the supply curve: a liquidity marker, a compromise between seller and buyer at a specific moment.

How does an appraiser arrive at a figure in practice? Most often by the discounted cash flow (DCF) method: forecasting revenue for several years, setting margins and a discount rate, and adding terminal value (the value beyond the forecast horizon of cash flows; it may be the main component of value for startups that are not yet profitable). It sounds scientific, but there are three problems here:

  • DCF does not assume bankruptcy—the method almost always proceeds from the idea of the business existing indefinitely. Terminal value, which may account for 40–60% of the entire valuation, is taken from a period about which no one can say anything for certain.
  • Enormous sensitivity to errors: change the discount rate by just 2–3 percentage points, and the value of the business will change by tens of percent.
  • DCF measures money, not value. It answers the question “how much money will the business bring,” but not the question “how much future will it preserve for the owner.” And these are different things: a business may potentially bring billions and at the same time contain a significant probability of collapse.

One should also use the popular technique of valuing a business by the prices of recent transactions with similar companies with caution. Each such price was formed under other conditions: with a different probability, a different time horizon, and a different dependence on the team and clients. Transferring it to one’s own transaction means substituting someone else’s P and T into the value formula instead of one’s own. Even very similar companies have very different values, because they always have very different futures.

What This Means for Those Buying or Selling a Business

Before naming a price, it is worth asking: for whom is it fair? For the founder, who is losing the work of his life—one figure. For the investor—another. For a competitor who wants to eliminate a player—a third. There is no single objective price; there is a price for a specific buyer here and now, in specific circumstances.

It is useful to translate the valuation of a business into hours, not only into money: how much time the product saves the client, how many hours of employees’ lives it consumes, what the probability is that the business will exist tomorrow, in a year, in ten years. These questions often give a more honest picture than a forecast of cash flows five years ahead.

It is also worth checking the transaction for irreversibility. Is there a realistic scenario in which the purchase or sale will lead to losses that cannot be corrected? If so, this is no longer an ordinary risk but a bet where one unsuccessful outcome can wipe out everything.

Instead of a Summary

The price of a business is merely a liquidity marker, a compromise between seller and buyer at a specific moment. Real value is the ability of a business to create and preserve time, to extend the future of a specific person or company in specific circumstances. It is not inherent in the business as a property; it arises in the interaction between the business and the context.

Therefore, the entrepreneur’s task is not simply to maximize the sale price but to understand what value his business creates, for whom, and under what circumstances. Because ultimately, value is preserved future. And the future is the only thing that truly matters.

The original article is here.